Qoutas

A narrative predicated on a gimmick needn’t be outlined by that gimmick. This identical season I am reviewing Handyman Saitō in Another World which I would beforehand praised for not basing all of its humor on that titular idea. And right here with Endo and Kobayashi, I am hardly anticipating all the present to function based mostly on the operating commentary of its personal title characters. There are separate tales unfolding on separate planes of actuality on this one, and I feel they each have core causes to be compelling, and naturally have an effect on each other the place they’ll applicably make one another extra attention-grabbing.

However such understandings do not imply that Endo and Kobayashi ought to be as cavalier with its major gimmick because it has been with these previous couple episodes, coming to a head on this fourth one. Fiene taking a summer season journey to Liese’s huge fancy dwelling means the women, and our two commentators who’re technically taking part in from Fiene’s perspective, are separated from Sieg and his heavenly listening to potential for an entire in-game season. Technically that simply signifies that Endo and Kobayashi have much less direct enter on occurrences in Love Me Magically than they’d gotten used to (although how a lot management they straight have over Fiene oddly by no means comes up). However in follow, the anime makes use of this as an excuse/alternative to excise Endo and Kobayashi from practically two-thirds of the entire episode, letting that primary visible novel plot play out sans any commentary or isekai interferences!

Now usually having individuals speaking over a narrative can be extra distracting, however Endo and Kobayashi had so successfully offered its central bit within the earlier episodes that the absence of our playing-along buddies is sorely noticeable throughout this stretch. The pair actually had ingratiated themselves with us; Kaito Ishikawa and Kana Hanazawa voice-acting jobs particularly make a enjoyable distinction with the supply of the otome recreation characters’ extra formal sensibilities. Sure, they most likely want to start out digging for extra materials than “Gee, Lieselotte positive is tsundere immediately, as common!”. However that is nonetheless one thing that overlays on high of the opposite a part of the present to create a definite taste, alongside the enjoyable that comes from them deciphering their interpretation of Liese’s actions and perspective.

So while you pull that again to simply concentrate on simply Liese interacting with Fiene sans any commentary, one thing is misplaced compared. A part of it’s that it highlights a shortcoming in Endo and Kobayashi‘s technique of motive supply when it is solely carried out in-universe. For example, one dialog that Fiene and Liese have over their Hearth Emblem Three Homes tea social gathering entails Liese spelling out for Fiene what Bal’s actions in direction of the heroine in final week’s episode actually meant. There’s really sort of an attention-grabbing learn in there, that Liese’s entire factor being how she’s not in-touch or trustworthy together with her emotions signifies that she will acknowledge the identical in Bal and name that out. However to then simply have her rotely clarify that to Fiene to advance her understanding (and potential relationship) with Bal is clunky. Having characters clarify how different characters really feel is just one step faraway from having characters gracelessly state their very own emotions. And if that may’t be prevented, it really works higher when the present makes use of the 2 greatest buddies taking part in this recreation who have been particularly right here to try this.

It is not like I am against the character interactions and whiffs of kingdom intrigue hinted at by way of a lot of this episode. However in leaving out the commentary observe for many of it, it comes off like Endo and Kobayashi forgetting so as to add its personal secret sauce. It is much more irritating as a result of the present appears to know that it had a chance. A too-brief cutaway highlights Endo and Kobayashi’s frustrations at not having the ability to talk as a result of Sieg is not round. It makes it too simple to think about an alternate model of those scenes the place the pair acknowledged moments of misunderstandings between Liese and Fiene, and we received to see their exasperated reactions at being unable to intervene. It ought to have been a straightforward alternative when it comes to the present utilizing its gimmick in a barely totally different manner than the previous episodes, and it will have made the fundamental bits of this episode extra attention-grabbing general.

I do not need to be that onerous on Endo and Kobayashi at this stage. The truth that stretches of the present like this one can nonetheless come throughout as earnest and attention-grabbing is value credit score for not utilizing the otome recreation backdrop as an excuse to take the piss. It is not a straightforward goal for the participant characters to MST3K over – it is a medium the creators clearly respect and need to inform their very own story inside. However the presentation of that story had been comparatively barebones for a purpose, and now that purpose is MIA for a lot of this episode. There’s nothing improper with a one-trick pony, as long as the trick is sufficiently neat. However it’s a must to keep in mind to have the horse really do the trick with some regularity.

Score:

Endo and Kobayashi Live! The Latest on Tsundere Villainess Lieselotte is at present streaming on
HIDIVE.

Chris is a freewheeling Fresno-based freelancer with a love for anime and a shelf stuffed with too many Transformers. He might be discovered spending manner an excessive amount of time on his Twitter, and irregularly updating his blog.

Disclosure: Kadokawa World Leisure (KWE), a completely owned subsidiary of Kadokawa Company, is almost all proprietor of Anime Information Community, LLC. A number of of the businesses talked about on this article are a part of the Kadokawa Group of Firms.