New York, New York Omnibus 2 – Review
For contemporary readers of BL, Marimo Ragawa‘s New York, New York could really feel very completely different from what they’re used to. Slightly than taking an idealized view of homosexual male relationships, the sequence, which dates to the mid-Nineteen Nineties, as an alternative makes an attempt a realism that the style is commonly devoid of. Neither of the protagonists is preternaturally stunning, and whereas there’s a sexual part to the story, it is not the be-all and end-all level. For Kain and Mel, the tip is a strong relationship that’s acknowledged as actual and legitimate by a world that is not fairly prepared to just accept homosexual marriage.
To that finish, it’s vital that the quantity opens with simply such a wedding. We rejoin Kain and Mel after they’ve returned to New York from Kain’s house in Newton, Massachusetts. Their assembly with Kain’s mother and father was considerably fraught, along with his mom not fairly prepared to just accept that her son is homosexual, however his father presents unconditional love. As chances are you’ll recall, in addition they misplaced Kain’s coworker, one other homosexual man, to AIDS, and the mixture of these items has satisfied the 2 to go forward with their marriage as a result of it merely is not value ready for the world to be prepared for them. The scene is simply as heartwarming and exquisite as you would possibly anticipate, maybe much more so when you keep in mind when homosexual marriage began to develop into authorized in numerous U.S. states; my sister was in center college when her piano trainer was lastly capable of marry his associate, albeit not in our state. Ragawa appears to know the importance of placing this second on paper. She would not make any larger of a deal of it than another Nineteen Nineties manga displaying a wedding scene, however there’s a placing quiet pleasure to their marriage that each exhibits us their happiness but in addition the stress surrounding their union; aside from the officiant, solely two visitors present as much as the ceremony.
Regretfully, that is one thing of a false flag for the second omnibus launch of Ragawa’s sequence. Kain and Mel’s happiness is fleeting, and the story takes a deep dive into cleaning soap opera territory. The day after their marriage ceremony, Mel is kidnapped by a serial killer whereas out taking a stroll; if that sounds somewhat excessive, nicely, it’s. A lot of the omnibus is taken up with Kain’s determined try to get Mel again, which includes teaming up with an FBI agent named Luna Pittsburg. The motion switches between Kain and Luna desperately monitoring down Mel’s captor and Mel himself within the clutches of Joey Klein, a mentally-ill man with a vendetta in opposition to blondes.
Earlier than you marvel how this has something to do with Kain and Mel’s relationship, there’s a distinct effort made to maintain the deal with the difficulties of being out of the closet in Nineteen Nineties New York. When Mel is kidnapped, Kain is actually pressured to return out at work, and whereas his commanding officer is completely positive with this (he and his spouse had been the 2 visitors on the marriage ceremony), different cops are far much less understanding. Kain faces not solely difficulties in making an attempt to get the police within the kidnapping of a homosexual man but in addition rampant homophobia within the police group as he tries to do his job whereas being personally concerned within the case. For probably the most half, the creator retains it on the refined facet, with the first plot focus being the precise kidnapping storyline. However it’s unimaginable to disregard the jabs and snark that Kain faces in his try to get his husband again, the insinuations of the media, his coworkers, and different brokers as they subtly disparage Kain for believing that Mel was kidnapped reasonably than run away of his personal volition. The implication is that nobody believes that two males could possibly be in a loving, dedicated relationship; that is simply as dangerous to Kain as Mel has been taken within the first place.
In amongst the entire melodrama surrounding Mel’s seize, we do see some actual positives. Major amongst them is when Kain’s mom realizes one thing is genuinely incorrect and that Mel is lacking. She stays with Kain in New York and helps him till the case is resolved. This, greater than something, exhibits how far she has are available in accepting her son for who he’s and acknowledging Mel as his husband. She in the end has chosen love over hate, and her actions are among the many most emotionally satisfying of the quantity. This turns into the triumphant theme of many of the e book, and if the best way that it’s depicted typically depends a bit too closely on the tropes of romantic suspense circa 1995, it’s in the end nicely sufficient carried out that the decision of the kidnapping plot and the reunion of our two lovers tugs on the heartstrings.
The e book additionally deserves recognition for its deal with Mel’s trauma. Being reunited with Kain isn’t a magic cure-all; Mel spent a month in captivity being raped by his captor, and on prime of that, by the hands of his father and through his transient time as a intercourse employee, he is acquired rather a lot to take care of. When Kain acknowledges that his husband wants assist, he would not instantly attempt to do the whole lot himself however as an alternative finds a therapist to go to. Not solely are the scenes with the therapist remarkably nonjudgmental for the time interval, however in addition they present that this can be a course of for each folks within the relationship. Kain additionally speaks to Mel’s therapist to discover ways to assist him finest. They determine what will probably be finest for each of them, and as soon as once more, the loving transformation undergone by Kain’s mom is there to help them as they discover a place they’ll actually name house.
In lots of circumstances, romance tales finish with fortunately ever after. We do not know what occurs to the characters after they lastly get collectively; we’re simply meant to just accept that the whole lot will probably be good from then on. That’s not essentially the strategy this sequence takes, and whereas many of the e book is instructed in an omniscient third particular person, the ultimate chapter is described within the first-person voice of Erica, the daughter Kain and Mel undertake. Erica’s narration exhibits us that life is not good, however it could possibly nonetheless be pretty much as good because it probably can, and whereas I would not have wished the e book to finish another means, I totally admit that I used to be crying on the finish. It is not truthful or proper to say that there’s not a cheerful ending; it is simply that reasonably than stopping on the most optimistic level, the story continues till it actually is the tip. Erica’s epilogue additionally exhibits that life does get simpler for Kain and Mel and that the homophobia that marked the early elements of their story, whereas nonetheless current, decreases its affect over their lifetime. That’s, for many people, the last word hopeful ending. Whereas New York, New York is marked by the point it was written, it’s in the end a satisfying work of fiction. This BL story defies the conventions of the style as we all know it at the moment, in the end making an attempt to depict the lives of two folks in a world that wasn’t prepared for them.
Kadokawa World Leisure (KWE), an entirely owned subsidiary of Kadokawa Company, is almost all proprietor of Anime Information Community, LLC. Yen Press, BookWalker World and J-Novel Membership are subsidiaries of KWE.