You Like Me, Not My Daughter?! GN 1 – Review
Age is a humorous factor. We have all learn manga that equates being over thirty with being middle-aged, and that basically drives dwelling the concept together with being a easy set of numbers that delineates how lengthy you’ve got been alive, age can be very a lot a social assemble and simply what that assemble is is dependent upon the tradition in query. Loads of manga dance round this concept, both enjoying it for laughs or titillation and within the case of age-gap shoujo manga, it is usually an indication that the heroine is probably extra mature than her peer group. Within the case of You Like Me, Not My Daughter?!, just about all of these items are true in a technique or one other.
The story follows a lady named Ayako, whose sister and brother-in-law died in an accident when their daughter Miu was solely 5 years previous. On the memorial, all the family argue over who will take within the orphaned little lady, and everybody has an excuse as to why it may possibly’t be them: they’ve too many children, they work an excessive amount of, it could look unhealthy in the event that they despatched her to a bunch dwelling. Annoyed with all of this and seeing the toll it is taking up the little lady, Ayako speaks up and says she’s going to step up and undertake her. Even when family attempt to dissuade her, saying that she has solely simply graduated from school and entered the workforce, Ayako is unmoved, and her dedication pays off. The story skips ahead ten years, and we will see that Miu is now calling her aunt her mom, and the 2 live a contented, comfy life. Miu has simply began highschool, and Ayako has organized the whole lot so she will do her work remotely, because of a really understanding boss. They’re even shut with the neighbors, notably their twenty-year-old son Takumi. He is been tutoring Miu, and Ayako has satisfied herself that he is received a crush on her daughter.
As you may guess from the title of the collection, this isn’t the case, and the individual he’s, in reality, in love with is Ayako herself. He has been for the previous ten years – within the funeral scene, we see a picture of him trying awed when Ayako stands up and says that if nobody else needs to absorb Miu, she’s going to. Clearly, he’s enthralled by this lady who has the center to do what not one of the older adults will, and if this have been the one marker of his early infatuation, the story would frankly work significantly better. Sadly, creator Kota Nozomi (of When Supernatural Battles Became Commonplace fame) determined that this was maybe not sufficient – or at the very least not attractive sufficient. Because the e book goes on, we be taught that ten years in the past, Ayako let Takumi into the home when his mom was out and he was caught within the rain, and the 2 of them took a shower collectively. Whereas there have been precisely zero sexual intentions on her half, for him, it was one thing of a sexual awakening, and the entire scene is extremely uncomfortable, particularly since he is uncomfortable with the scenario and unwilling to say so. Tub scenes wouldn’t have to be inherently attractive, however that little Takumi felt that it was casts a pall over what in any other case might have been a superbly advantageous romantic comedy.
It additionally feels just a little misplaced, provided that the remainder of the story primarily includes Takumi attempting his finest to make it clear that he’s 100% severe about her whereas she flutters round, proclaiming that she is just too previous for him. Whereas there’s at the very least an eleven- or twelve-year age hole between them, she is the one one bothered by it; even his mom is completely okay together with her son’s emotions since he made them clear to her. There seem like two elements to Ayako’s points on the topic. One is undoubtedly the truth that she has recognized him since he was ten; we will extrapolate that she and Miu moved into Miu’s household dwelling, thereby gaining Takumi and his household as neighbors. She’s all the time seen him, due to this fact, because the little child subsequent door, and realizing that he has grown up is troublesome for her. However she’s additionally feeling a lot older than her bodily age would counsel. And that is virtually actually partially as a result of she raised a baby for ten years; it places her in an expertise bracket that’s maybe not shared by her age mates. Since in her head she’s been Miu’s mom for the previous decade, she assumes that that is how Takumi sees her; equally, since there’s double the variety of years between her and Takumi as there’s between Takumi and Miu, she will’t think about that he would not really feel nearer to her daughter than to herself. She’s floored to understand that Takumi sees himself as a full-grown grownup and acts like one. He is severe about her, and the best way he views her is so completely different from the best way she sees herself that she turns into the only greatest obstacle to them even having a daily dialog on the topic, which admittedly does result in some hilarious makes an attempt to show him off; the otaku one is very humorous.
If age-gap romances aren’t your factor, this one will most likely not be just right for you. The tub scene is near a deal breaker even with out that issue. Nonetheless, in case you can look past that and poor Ayako’s extremely uncomfortable-looking breasts, there’s a first rate story right here that is fairly candy. There’s one thing unhappy about Ayako having written herself off as an previous woman at thirty-one or thirty-two years previous. The individuals round her are all extremely supportive of no matter resolution she makes. Apparently sufficient, the included brief story from Takumi’s perspective is written in his first-person voice, so it could be fascinating to know whether or not or not the novels are written in the identical means or if that was one thing particular finished for this explicit brief story. However this general doesn’t scream adaptation, and with these few caveats I discussed earlier than, it is likely to be a pleasant piece of escapist romance fantasy.